It’s tempting to think of audits as something only big corporations worry about, but when you’re on an HOA board in Florida, the question of whether a Florida HOA audit is needed comes up more often than you’d expect. After all, accuracy, accountability, and confidence are cornerstones of good governance.
Why Would an HOA Even Need an Audit?
An HOA audit goes beyond a dry review of spreadsheets. It’s a formal, independent examination of a homeowners association’s financial records, conducted by licensed HOA auditors. Think of it like your community’s annual health check-up, but for finances. The auditor’s job is to review transactions, test balances, verify compliance, and ultimately, give the board (and homeowners) peace of mind that everything is in order.
And let’s be honest, if a resident challenges a dues increase or questions a major contract payment, having an audit report on hand can quickly diffuse tension. It adds a layer of credibility that internal reviews alone can’t always provide.
What Triggers an Audit Under Florida Law?
According to Florida HOA audit requirements under Chapter 720 of the Florida Statutes, whether your HOA must conduct an audit depends primarily on revenue. The thresholds are crystal clear:
- Over $500,000 in total revenues? A full audit is legally required.
- $300,000 to $500,000? A review is needed, which is less intensive than an audit but should still be done by professionals.
- $150,000 to $300,000? A compilation is required. This still involves an outside CPA, but its scope is limited.
- Below $150,000? There’s no audit requirement, unless your governing documents or members say otherwise.
But even when it’s not legally mandated, some HOAs voluntarily commission audits anyway. Why? Because reputation matters. If you’re managing reserves for roof replacements or storm recovery funds, members want reassurance that their money isn’t vanishing into thin air.
Are HOA Audits and Reviews the Same?
Not quite. It’s a bit like comparing a general check-up to an MRI.
An audit digs deep. It’s comprehensive and includes verification of documents, testing of transactions, and assessment of internal controls. HOA auditors may physically inspect bank statements, trace expenses to vendor invoices, and even verify dues payments.
A review, on the other hand, is more limited in scope. Auditors use analytical procedures to assess plausibility rather than scrutinising every ledger entry. You’ll still get a report, but with less detail.
So, what’s the smarter option? That depends on your HOA’s size, complexity, and risk appetite. If your community has large reserve accounts, a history of management turnover, or any indication of financial irregularity, consider opting for an audit every time.
What HOA Auditors Look For
In addition to verifying that the numbers match, HOA auditors also need to read between the lines.
Here are some things auditors examine:
- Income: Are assessments being appropriately collected?
- Expenses: Do disbursements match approved budgets and contracts?
- Reserves: Is the reserve account properly funded and utilized?
- Compliance: Are financial practices in line with Florida statutes and governing documents?
- Internal controls: Are there checks and balances in place to prevent errors or fraud?
And while no one likes the idea of “fraud,” it happens, even in small, quiet communities. Sometimes, it’s as mundane as double-billing. Other times, it’s more serious. A Florida HOA audit identifies problems and helps prevent them.
When Residents Start Asking Questions
The board may feel confident in its oversight, but what about the residents?
Transparency is a loaded word in HOA circles. When owners see rising HOA fees or special assessments, they want justification. An audit provides precisely that. It informs them that their money has been handled appropriately or flags issues before they become a problem.
Under Florida law, if 20% of the voting interests in a community request an audit, the board must arrange one, even if the community’s income doesn’t meet the typical thresholds.
What Happens If You Skip It?
Ignoring audit requirements can bite back. If your HOA is legally required to conduct an audit and fails to do so, that could result in:
- Legal consequences: Fines or penalties depending on how egregious the non-compliance is
- Member lawsuits: Especially if funds go missing or records are mismanaged
- Loss of confidence: Once trust is broken, good luck getting owners to approve the following special assessment
Even worse, some management companies don’t notify boards when audits are due. They’ll handle day-to-day bookkeeping but avoid raising the audit flag unless asked. That’s why boards must remain aware of their responsibilities, regardless of how hands-off management may be.
The Florida HOA Audit Process: What to Expect
Truthfully, a Florida HOA audit doesn’t have to be a hassle if your records are clean. The process typically unfolds like this:
- Engagement letter signed between the board and a CPA
- Document requests, such as bank statements, invoices, reserve studies, budgets, minutes, etc.
- Initial walkthrough of procedures and controls
- Testing and verification by the auditors
- Draft report issued, followed by any clarifications
- Final audit report delivered, usually within 30 to 60 days
The board doesn’t need to hover over the process, but it should stay engaged. Answer questions quickly. Make sure the manager provides complete records. If the auditor suggests changes to internal processes, take them seriously and implement them effectively. That’s where a lot of value hides—in the feedback.
Choosing the Right HOA Auditors
When choosing HOA editors, you have to scrutinize all possible candidates. You should look for the following characteristics:
- Specializing in community associations
- Know Florida law and have experience with local HOA accounting quirks
- Are licensed and insured
- Provide sample reports or references from other communities
Ask about timing, cost, and communication style. Some CPAs are incredibly technical and hard to follow—others know how to break it down for regular people. You’ll want the latter.
Depending on the size of your HOA, the audit cost can range from $2,000 to $7,000 or more. Yes, that’s a significant amount of money. But so is a leaky roof—only audits protect something more fragile: your credibility.
A Needed Check
An audit won’t solve every problem in an HOA, but it clears the fog. When one’s done right, an audit clears the air and puts questions to rest. Sometimes, knowing where things stand is worth more than any line item in the budget.
Need professional help with your Florida HOA audits? Freedom Community Management provides HOA management services in Florida. Call us at 904-490-8191 or contact us online to learn more!
RELATED ARTICLE:
